BedBoy earns a commission when you buy through a retailer link. The commission never changes a score. How this works
Best mattress guides

Best extra firm mattresses in the UK

Last updated . Prices read . Read how we score.

The short answer

Top pick for extra firm mattresses is the TheraPur ActiGel® Arctic 3000 Combination Mattress at 4.3 / 5. The Dream Team Fakenham 1000 Pocket Ortho Mattress is second on 4.3 / 5. List prices run from £395.00 up to £1,499.00.

How we ranked this list

Durability counts thirty per cent more than usual here, edge support twenty per cent more. A very firm build is bought for support that doesn't give, and those two marks show whether it keeps it. To qualify, a mattress must carry that model's own grade of extra firm, very firm or firm to very firm. It is removed when complaints about its comfort or about sagging, from at least five owners, outnumber the owners pleased with it. Mattresses whose owners are firmly positive about how they last are listed first, ahead of the rest whatever their marks.

The category weightings, the source data and how every score is built are set out on the how we score page.

BedBoy's firmness filter tops out at firm, so every extra firm mattress gets filed in with the plain firm ones. They're a grade further on. I'd only send you to this end of the range if you're heavy, you sleep on your front, or you've slept on firm before and still felt yourself sinking.

So this list goes by the maker's word for that exact model. 16 adult mattresses carry a listing that grades them extra firm, very firm or firm to very firm, and each has enough BedBoy Score marks to rank. In the table, the firmness column reads Firm for every one of them, because BedBoy's scale stops there. Any line saying the model also comes in an extra firm version under another name doesn't count. Durability and edge support carry the extra weight in the order.

Everything graded plain firm or medium-firm sits on the firm list. The firm mattresses page has the whole range side by side.

Our top picks at a glance

Best extra firm mattresses in the UK
Mattress Price Firmness Extra-firm fit BedBoy Score Customer rating
TheraPur ActiGel® Arctic 3000 Combination Mattress£1,499.00Firm4.6 / 54.3 / 54.6 / 5 (34)
Dream Team Fakenham 1000 Pocket Ortho Mattress£599.00Firm4.5 / 54.3 / 54.7 / 5 (1,258)
Dream Team Ludlow 1000 Pocket Memory Mattress£399.00Firm4.5 / 54.3 / 54.8 / 5 (503)
Dream Team Gold Corsham 5600 Pocket Memory Mattress£1,299.00Firm4.5 / 54.3 / 54.7 / 5 (186)
Rest Assured Adleborough 1400 Pocket Ortho Mattress£395.00Firm4.4 / 54.2 / 54.6 / 5 (378)
Dream Team Amersham 1200 Pocket Ortho Mattress£499.00Firm4.4 / 54.2 / 54.8 / 5 (336)
Rest Assured Northington 2000 Pocket Natural Mattress£434.00Firm4.4 / 54.1 / 54.6 / 5 (163)
Sealy Catalonia Ortho Extra Firm Mattress£949.99Firm4.4 / 54.4 / 54.8 / 5 (77)
Sleepeezee Regency Kenilworth 1600 Pocket Sprung Mattress£1,124.00Firm4.4 / 54.2 / 54.7 / 5 (49)
Relyon Heyford Ortho 1500 Pocket Mattress£648.00Firm4.4 / 54.2 / 54.8 / 5 (46)

The picks in detail

1. TheraPur ActiGel® Arctic 3000 Combination Mattress

4.6/5
Extra-firm fit
4.3/5
BedBoy Score
£1,499.00
Listed at
Firm
Firmness
4.6/5
34 reviews

Graded firm-very firm, on 2586 pocket springs plus micro springs under a graphite-infused cover, the Arctic 3000 is a hot sleeper's mattress for people sure that firm suits them. Owners who chose it for firmness report cool nights and aching backs and shoulders gone, while couples who find it the wrong firmness, one pair despite liking firm, send it back.

Check price at DreamsPrice read

Read the review

2. Dream Team Fakenham 1000 Pocket Ortho Mattress

4.5/5
Extra-firm fit
4.3/5
BedBoy Score
£599.00
Listed at
Firm
Firmness
4.7/5
1,258 reviews

If you want a hard bed for a bad back, the Fakenham is built for you: a very firm, double-sided pocket-sprung ortho mattress, 22cm deep, that you flip. Back-pain sleepers are its loudest fans. The deep tufting and the sheer firmness are what send others back, so anyone wanting sink should pass.

Check price at DreamsPrice read

Read the review

3. Dream Team Ludlow 1000 Pocket Memory Mattress

4.5/5
Extra-firm fit
4.3/5
BedBoy Score
£399.00
Listed at
Firm
Firmness
4.8/5
503 reviews

The Ludlow is a firm to very firm pocket spring mattress with memory foam on top, 22cm deep and only 25kg, so it is easy to rotate. Owners who already know they like firm, back-pain sufferers among them, rate it strong value, while anyone who wants to sink in should look elsewhere.

Check price at DreamsPrice read

Read the review

4. Dream Team Gold Corsham 5600 Pocket Memory Mattress

4.5/5
Extra-firm fit
4.3/5
BedBoy Score
£1,299.00
Listed at
Firm
Firmness
4.7/5
186 reviews

The Corsham is graded very firm: pocket springs topped by graphite-infused memory foam and a plush pillow layer, inside a bamboo cover, and back sufferers who want a hard, flat base are its strongest fans. The button tufts leave deep dimples in the surface, so if an uneven top would keep you awake, pass.

Check price at DreamsPrice read

Read the review

5. Rest Assured Adleborough 1400 Pocket Ortho Mattress

4.4/5
Extra-firm fit
4.2/5
BedBoy Score
£395.00
Listed at
Firm
Firmness
4.6/5
378 reviews

Extra firm and orthopaedic: 1400 pocket springs, a thin tufted layer of soft fibres, one sleeping side. People with bad backs are its loudest supporters, and its regretful buyers found it hard enough to need a topper. A genuinely hard surface is the whole point; anyone wanting cushioning on top needs a softer grade.

Check price at Mattress OnlinePrice read

Read the review

6. Dream Team Amersham 1200 Pocket Ortho Mattress

4.4/5
Extra-firm fit
4.2/5
BedBoy Score
£499.00
Listed at
Firm
Firmness
4.8/5
336 reviews

Very firm means very firm here: 1073 pocket springs and a British wool layer in a double-sided build, 25cm deep. Owners with a bad back and a liking for a hard surface love it, while those expecting the showroom feel compare it to the floor. Only order it if you already know you sleep well on firm.

Check price at DreamsPrice read

Read the review

7. Rest Assured Northington 2000 Pocket Natural Mattress

4.4/5
Extra-firm fit
4.1/5
BedBoy Score
£434.00
Listed at
Firm
Firmness
4.6/5
163 reviews

A natural-filled extra firm mattress: 2000 pocket springs under cashmere, silk and wool, tufted and single-sided. Owners who want a truly hard bed get one, and bad backs do well on it. Its drawback is sheer weight on moving day. A softer top means budgeting for a topper.

Check price at Mattress OnlinePrice read

Read the review

8. Sealy Catalonia Ortho Extra Firm Mattress

4.4/5
Extra-firm fit
4.4/5
BedBoy Score
£949.99
Listed at
Firm
Firmness
4.8/5
77 reviews

Built extra firm, this 27cm Sealy pairs a PostureTech spring core and EdgeGuard edges with a PowerPack zone for hip and lower-back support, and owners who hunted for a truly firm mattress, bad backs included, found it here. Allow a week to adjust; anyone wanting some give belongs on the Firm Support version.

Check price at Bensons for BedsPrice read

Read the review

9. Sleepeezee Regency Kenilworth 1600 Pocket Sprung Mattress

4.4/5
Extra-firm fit
4.2/5
BedBoy Score
£1,124.00
Listed at
Firm
Firmness
4.7/5
49 reviews

Very firm, bamboo-filled and pocket sprung, the Kenilworth carries a 10-year guarantee and works on adjustable bases. Its strongest supporters are back pain sufferers, who call it firm and comfortable in one breath. If sinking into a mattress is what you like, its solid feel is a poor match.

Check price at DreamsPrice read

Read the review

10. Relyon Heyford Ortho 1500 Pocket Mattress

4.4/5
Extra-firm fit
4.2/5
BedBoy Score
£648.00
Listed at
Firm
Firmness
4.8/5
46 reviews

Extra firm, double-sided and 32cm deep, the Heyford Ortho puts 1500 pocket springs under cotton fillings and a damask cover. Its owners wanted a hard bed for their backs and got one. The criticism is about dips and a missing handle, not firmness, and a sleeper who likes bounce or sink should go softer.

Check price at Mattress OnlinePrice read

Read the review

Very firm starts with the wire

In a sprung mattress the grade comes mostly from the springs. Lower gauge numbers mean thicker wire, and thicker wire makes a stiffer spring. Coil count, spring height and the fillings change the feel too, so I read the gauge as a clue and the grade as the answer.

Foam extra firm builds get there with dense base foam and very little on top. Judge those on what owners say about comfort.

Light sleepers and sore backs should look elsewhere

If you're light, skip this list. The heavier you are, the firmer the tension you need, and a light body barely presses into a very firm mattress at all. Front sleeping is the least common position: the 664 adults in Skarpsno's accelerometer study spent just 7.3 per cent of their time in bed face down. Side sleepers should usually look elsewhere too. When researchers tracked the spines of 25 men lying on their side, alignment differed significantly between soft, firm and zoned surfaces.

Nor is a sore back a reason on its own. In Kovacs's trial of 313 people with chronic low back pain, medium-firm beat firm on pain in bed and on disability at 90 days. Read the back pain guide first. Heavier and face-down sleepers should also see the heavier sleepers and front sleepers lists.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between firm and extra firm?

Extra firm is the next grade up in a maker's own range, with less give where you press hardest and a surface you lie on more than in. That difference comes from the spring tension or the foam density rather than the cover. Grades are each maker's own, so an extra firm from one brand can feel close to another's firm. Compare within one range, and lie on both grades side by side if a shop has them.

Who should buy an extra firm mattress?

Heavier adults and front sleepers who find firm still lets them sink. Heavier bodies press further into a mattress, so they need a stiffer spring or denser foam to stay level. Front sleepers need their pelvis kept up in line with their ribs, or the small of the back arches. If you've never found a firm mattress too soft, you probably don't need this grade, and the firm list is the better place to start.

Is an orthopaedic mattress extra firm?

Not necessarily. Orthopaedic is a maker's word for a firmer build and isn't a regulated grade, so an orthopaedic mattress can be graded firm, very firm or medium-firm. This list ignores the word and goes by the firmness grade the maker gives that model. If you're shopping on the name, read the firmness line on the specification first, because that's the part the maker commits to.

Will an extra firm mattress soften over time?

A little, mostly in the top layers over the first few months as the fillings settle under your weight. The spring unit or base foam underneath shouldn't change much. Body impressions in the fillings are normal, and rotating the mattress keeps them down. A dip in the middle within the first year is more than settling, and owner complaints about it are what knock a mattress off this list.

Can a side sleeper use an extra firm mattress?

Rarely well. On your side, your shoulder and hip need to sink a little so your spine stays level. Very firm surfaces push back at both points instead. If your partner needs extra firm and you sleep on your side, look at doubles made from two singles zipped together, which can come in split tensions.

References

  1. 1. Skarpsno ES and others (2017). Sleep positions and nocturnal body movements based on free-living accelerometer recordings. Nature and Science of Sleep, doi:10.2147/NSS.S145777.
  2. 2. Leilnahari K and others (2011). Spine alignment in men during lateral sleep position: experimental study and modeling. BioMedical Engineering OnLine, pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov.
  3. 3. Kovacs FM and others (2003). Effect of firmness of mattress on chronic non-specific low-back pain: randomised, double-blind, controlled, multicentre trial. The Lancet, doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(03)14792-7.

How this list is ordered

Each composite is built from the manufacturer's own specification, live retailer pricing and the pooled reviews of people who own the mattress. Every category score, and the source behind every figure, is published on the how we score page, so you can check the working rather than take our word for it.

Brands can't pay for placement, and the affiliate networks don't see the running order before it goes out. When the inputs change, the order moves with them.

Still weighing up the options?

If the shortlist above hasn't settled it for you, the mattress quiz narrows the whole catalogue by how you sleep, your build and your budget, and hands back something shorter.