BedBoy earns a commission when you buy through a retailer link. The commission never changes a score. How this works
Help and advice

How to choose a mattress

Published

A neatly made bed in a calm, softly lit bedroom, with a knitted throw folded across the foot of the mattress

Start with your body and the way you lie, and only then look at what the mattress is made of. How far you sink comes down to your sleeping position and your weight, and how the mattress pushes back comes down to the build. The budget and the returns terms fix what a wrong guess costs you. Take those decisions in that order and most of the range sorts itself out before you've read a single product name.

Your sleeping position sets the starting firmness

Side sleepers start softest, back sleepers in the middle and front sleepers firmest, because of where your weight goes. On your side, most of it goes through a shoulder and a hip, two fairly small surfaces. You need a top layer that lets both sink in far enough for your spine to stay level. On your back, your weight is spread along your whole length, and a medium to medium-firm surface keeps your hips from dropping lower than your shoulders.

A mattress with the duvet folded back, showing the soft hollow a sleeper leaves in it
On your side, your weight goes through your shoulder and hip, which is why side sleepers start softer.

On your front, the danger runs the other way. A soft top lets your hips sag and arches your lower back, so front sleeping is the one position that starts at the firm end.

Firmness finder

Where to start on firmness

Two answers give you a starting band, with your weight already counted in it. Lie on anything before you commit, and read a label only within its own maker's range.

Every starting band
Starting bands by position and weight. This is retail convention rather than a clinical threshold.
PositionUnder 10 stone (63 kg)10 to 15 stone (63 to 95 kg)Over 15 stone (95 kg)
On my sideSoft to soft-mediumSoft-medium to mediumMedium to medium-firm
On my backSoft-medium to mediumMedium to medium-firmMedium-firm to firm
On my frontMedium to medium-firmMedium-firm to firmFirm
All over the placeSoft-mediumMediumMedium-firm

Back or neck pain, a partner, a budget? The mattress quiz weighs those too.

If you change position through the night, buy for the one you spend longest in, and if you can't tell, start at medium. For most people that's the side: in a Danish study that tracked sleeping position with body-worn sensors, adults spent just over half their time in bed on their side, more than a third on their back and under a tenth face down.

Your weight moves you up or down a band

The same mattress feels firmer under a light body and softer under a heavy one. A heavier sleeper presses further into the comfort layers before the support underneath takes over. The starting band for your position assumes an average weight.

If you're under 10 stone (63 kg), go one band softer than your position alone gives. If you're over 15 stone (95 kg), go a band firmer and judge the support unit before the top layers. A thin foam top over a weak core is what sags first. The picks for heavier sleepers are medium-firm and firm sprung builds with strong durability or edge evidence, and owner complaints about sagging rule a mattress out.

Firmer does not mean better for your back

Medium-firm beat firm in Kovacs's 2003 Lancet trial, which put 313 adults with chronic non-specific low back pain on one or the other for 90 days. The medium-firm group reported less pain in bed and less disability. At 90 days, pain on rising also favoured medium-firm without reaching significance. The trial had no soft arm either, so it tells you to avoid the firm end and says nothing about how soft is too soft. I read it as a reason to start at medium-firm and stop there.

Orthopaedic on a UK label is the maker's word for a firmer build, and no standard sits behind it. The back pain picks are medium to medium-firm springs or latex with good pressure-relief scores, and any mattress owners mostly fault for pain or sagging is left out.

How each build feels to lie on

Pocket sprung: each spring sits in its own fabric pocket and moves on its own, so a partner turning over moves your side less than on an open coil. Air also moves freely through the springs. Pocket sprung mattresses are the default I'd start most people on.

Open coil: the springs are wired together into one unit. It's the cheapest spring build and the one where movement travels furthest, which is fine for one sleeper and a poor bargain for two.

Memory foam: it softens with heat and moulds slowly to you, which is the sinking-in feeling side sleepers often like and some people find hard to turn over in. If you run warm, check the owners' heat comments on a memory foam mattress's page before you buy, and pass on one whose page has none.

Latex: it gives under you and springs back at once, so you lie on it rather than in it. Latex mattresses suit you if you like contouring but hate the slow feel of memory foam.

Hybrid: pocket springs under a deeper layer of foam or latex, so it feels halfway between a sprung mattress and a foam one. Hybrid mattresses suit you if you want some sink without losing the push of the springs.

Live from the BedBoy catalogue: active mattresses of each build and their current prices across the retailers we compare, at the size each listing leads with.
BuildMattressesFromAverage
Pocket sprung151£153£1,012
Memory foam82£149£930
Latex34£540£1,563
Hybrid13£168£821

Sharing a bed or sleeping hot

If you share, let the partner who sleeps lighter choose the build. Pocket springs and foam both keep movement on one side better than an open coil. On the couples picks, the partner-movement score carries the most weight, and open coils are left out.

If you overheat, the cover and the top layer count for more than any cooling name on the label. The hot sleepers list leaves out all-foam memory builds and anything owners mostly call hot, and keeps latex, springs with a cooling layer and mattresses owners say sleep cool.

Set the budget from the size and the build

Go for the best value rather than the lowest price, and here's the test I use: a £250 mattress that dips inside two years has cost you more a night than a £600 one that lasts six. Decide the size first, because a king costs more than a double in every build, and then see what your budget buys in it. The picks under £500 and under £1,000 show what each budget buys.

Count on about seven years from a mattress, the replacement point on the bed trade's own Bed Advice UK site, so divide the price by seven before you decide a dearer one is out of reach.

Read the returns terms before the price

Buying online, you can cancel within 14 days of receiving the mattress, for any reason, under the Consumer Contracts Regulations 2013. You then have another 14 days to send it back.

A comfort trial is the retailer's own promise on top of that, with terms that differ a great deal. Some trials are an exchange rather than a refund, some only let you return after a minimum number of nights, and some charge a fee. Read those conditions on the retailer's page before you compare prices, and write down the date your trial ends.

In a shop, give each mattress at least 10 minutes, lying in your usual position, and with your partner if you share. Ten minutes feels like a long time to lie on a bed in a showroom. Do it anyway.

What to steer clear of

  • A firm mattress bought for a bad back: the Lancet trial above put medium-firm ahead of firm, so skip the firmest you can find.
  • A firmness label read across brands: one maker's medium can be another's medium-firm.
  • A thin foam top over an open coil, for two people: movement travels and the top layer flattens where you both lie.
  • A trial you haven't read: an exchange-only trial with a fee is not a refund.
  • A new mattress on an old, sagging base: the old base can shorten the new mattress's life and can invalidate the maker's guarantee.

Get the size right first with the UK mattress sizes guide. If you'd rather answer three questions than read the lot, the mattress quiz turns your position, your weight and any back or neck pain into a starting band. Every product score is explained on how we score.

Questions people ask

What firmness of mattress should I get?

Start from how you sleep. Side sleepers usually do best at soft-medium to medium, back sleepers at medium to medium-firm, and front sleepers at medium-firm to firm. Then adjust for your weight: one band softer if you're under about 10 stone, one firmer if you're over about 15. Treat that as a starting band, not a prescription, and remember a label only means something within its own maker's range.

How long should a mattress last?

About seven years is a sensible yardstick for most mattresses. Some last longer, and a cheap one may not get there. The better test is your own: if it has started to dip where you lie, you wake stiff and ease up once you're moving, or you sleep better in a hotel bed, it's time to look.

Can I send a mattress back if it isn't right?

Bought online, you can cancel within 14 days of receiving it for any reason under the cooling-off rules, then send it back. A retailer's comfort trial is a separate promise with its own terms, and some trials are exchange-only, need a minimum number of nights or charge a fee. Read those terms before you buy, not after the mattress has arrived and been slept on.

References

  1. Skarpsno ES and others. Sleep positions and nocturnal body movements based on free-living accelerometer recordings: association with demographics, lifestyle, and insomnia symptoms. Nature and Science of Sleep, 2017. https://doi.org/10.2147/NSS.S145777
  2. Kovacs FM et al. Effect of firmness of mattress on chronic non-specific low-back pain: randomised, double-blind, controlled, multicentre trial. The Lancet, 2003. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(03)14792-7
  3. Bed Advice UK: is it time you had a new mattress, the seven-year replacement guide. https://bedadvice.co.uk/is-it-time-you-had-a-new-mattress/
  4. The Consumer Contracts (Information, Cancellation and Additional Charges) Regulations 2013, regulations 30 and 35: the cancellation period and returning goods. https://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2013/3134/contents