Dreams Workshop Botfield Traditional Spring vs Dreams Workshop Edwards Traditional Spring Memory vs Silentnight Aloe Vera Portloe Miracoil Ortho Traditional Spring Mattress
Three mattresses, all sold by Dreams
The short answer
The Dreams Workshop Edwards Traditional Spring Memory scores highest at 4.2/5, ahead of the Dreams Workshop Botfield Traditional Spring (3.8) and the Silentnight Aloe Vera Portloe Miracoil Ortho Traditional Spring (3.6). The Silentnight Aloe Vera Portloe Miracoil Ortho Traditional Spring has too few reviews yet to mark comfort or value, so its score rests on fewer categories. The Dreams Workshop Botfield Traditional Spring is the cheapest in a double at £279, £20 less than the Dreams Workshop Edwards Traditional Spring Memory.
-
Why pick it
- Cheapest in a double: £279, against £299 and £299
- More owner reviews to go on: 2,829, against 509 and 38
-
Why pick it
- Softer feel: Medium, against Firm
- Scores higher on motion isolation: 4.5 against 2.5
- Scores higher on pressure relief: 4.5 against 3.0
-
Silentnight Aloe Vera Portloe Miracoil Ortho Traditional Spring
at Dreams
3.6/5 Good
£299
Check priceWhy pick it
- Longer guarantee: 5 years, against 1 year
Price and sizes
| Detail | Dreams Workshop Botfield Traditional Spring | Dreams Workshop Edwards Traditional Spring Memory | Silentnight Aloe Vera Portloe Miracoil Ortho Traditional Spring |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price in a double |
£279Lowest
|
£299
|
£299
|
| Single 90 x 190 cm |
£199Lowest
|
£249
|
£261
|
| King 150 x 200 cm |
Not sold
|
£349
|
£336Lowest
|
| Small Double 120 x 190 cm |
Not sold
|
£299
|
£299
|
| Super King 180 x 200 cm |
Not sold
|
£399
|
£374Lowest
|
Prices read from each retailer on 21 November 2026. The retailer’s checkout has the final price.
BedBoy Score
| Detail | Dreams Workshop Botfield Traditional Spring | Dreams Workshop Edwards Traditional Spring Memory | Silentnight Aloe Vera Portloe Miracoil Ortho Traditional Spring |
|---|---|---|---|
| BedBoy Score |
3.8/5 Good
|
4.2/5 Very goodBest
|
3.6/5 Good
|
| Comfort |
5.0/5
|
5.0/5
|
Too few reviews
|
| Pressure relief |
3.0/5
|
4.5/5Best
|
3.0/5
|
| Edge support |
3.0/5
|
3.0/5
|
3.0/5
|
| Motion isolation |
2.5/5
|
4.5/5Best
|
2.5/5
|
| Heat retention |
4.0/5
|
4.0/5
|
4.0/5
|
| Durability |
3.0/5
|
3.5/5Best
|
2.5/5
|
| Value |
5.0/5
|
5.0/5
|
Too few reviews
|
| Off-gassing and setup |
5.0/5
|
4.0/5
|
5.0/5
|
| Customer sentiment |
4.6/5
|
4.7/5
|
4.6/5
|
| Retailer guarantee |
3.3/5
|
3.3/5
|
4.0/5Best
|
| Same on all three: Edge support 3.0 · Heat retention 4.0 | |||
Each mark is out of 5, from owner reviews and the specification. How the score is made.
What owners say
| Detail | Dreams Workshop Botfield Traditional Spring | Dreams Workshop Edwards Traditional Spring Memory | Silentnight Aloe Vera Portloe Miracoil Ortho Traditional Spring |
|---|---|---|---|
| Owners rate it |
4.6/5
|
4.7/5
|
4.6/5
|
| Comfort |
93% positive
|
96% positive
|
Too few mentions
|
| Value |
99% positive
|
100% positive
|
Too few mentions
|
| Durability |
70% positive
|
Too few mentions
|
Too few mentions
|
Share of the reviews that mention each topic which are positive about it, out of the reviews with written comments. How the counts work.
Firmness and feel
| Detail | Dreams Workshop Botfield Traditional Spring | Dreams Workshop Edwards Traditional Spring Memory | Silentnight Aloe Vera Portloe Miracoil Ortho Traditional Spring |
|---|---|---|---|
| Firmness |
Firm
|
Medium
|
Firm
|
What it is made of
| Detail | Dreams Workshop Botfield Traditional Spring | Dreams Workshop Edwards Traditional Spring Memory | Silentnight Aloe Vera Portloe Miracoil Ortho Traditional Spring |
|---|---|---|---|
| Layers Top to bottom |
|
|
|
| Build |
Open coil
|
Open coil, memory foam
|
Open coil
|
| Depth |
18 cm
|
21 cm
|
24 cm
|
| Spring type |
Open coil
|
Open coil
|
Open coil
|
| Spring count |
288
|
288
|
672
|
| Fillings |
Not stated
|
Memory foam
|
Recycled fibre
|
| Made in |
UK
|
UK
|
UK
|
| Same on all three: Spring type Open coil · Made in UK | |||
Trial, guarantee and care
| Detail | Dreams Workshop Botfield Traditional Spring | Dreams Workshop Edwards Traditional Spring Memory | Silentnight Aloe Vera Portloe Miracoil Ortho Traditional Spring |
|---|---|---|---|
| Trial |
100 nights (comfort guarantee)Comfort guarantee (an exchange between night 30 and 100, £95 charge)
|
100 nights (comfort guarantee)Comfort guarantee (an exchange between night 30 and 100, £95 charge)
|
100 nights (comfort guarantee)Comfort guarantee (an exchange between night 30 and 100, £95 charge)
|
| Guarantee |
1 year
|
1 year
|
5 yearsBest
|
| Returns |
Returns within 14 days with a £49 collection charge
|
Returns within 14 days with a £49 collection charge
|
Returns within 14 days with a £49 collection charge
|
| Turning |
Rotate only, no flipping
|
Rotate only, no flipping
|
Rotate only, no flipping
|
| Sleeping faces |
Single-sided (one sleeping face)
|
Single-sided (one sleeping face)
|
Single-sided (one sleeping face)
|
| Weight |
Not stated
|
27 kg
|
Not stated
|
| Same on all three: Trial 100 nights (comfort guarantee) · Returns within 14 days with a £49 collection charge · Turning Rotate only, no flipping · Sleeping faces Single-sided (one sleeping face) | |||
Questions about this comparison
How is the BedBoy Score worked out?
The score is the plain average of the category marks for that product type. BedBoy marks each listing using the customer reviews held against it and the seller's published specification, with a mark from how the product is built where reviewers say little about a category. The categories depend on the product type. Read how the score is made for the detail behind those marks.
Are the prices on this page live?
No. Each price is the figure BedBoy last read from the retailer, and the date under the price table tells you when that was. A sale price can come and go between reads, so check the retailer's checkout before you pay.
Why is the same product listed once per retailer?
Trial length, warranty and returns differ by shop. Each listing is tied to a retailer because the same mattress can leave you with different rights if it turns out wrong, depending on where you bought it. Compare the terms as well as what you'll pay. The retailer guarantee row is marked on that shop's trial, warranty and returns terms.



