BedBoy earns a commission when you buy through a retailer link. The commission never changes a score. How this works
Silentnight at Mattress Online · BedBoy review

Silentnight Bonnell Mattress

BedBoy Score 3.5/5 Good

from £178

Owners rate it 4.5/5 (360 reviews)

Rating

BedBoy Score

The BedBoy Score is the plain average of the scored categories, out of 5. Each bar counts what this product's reviewers wrote about that category or, where they said little, marks its build, and the line underneath says which (see how the score is made). Open the category that matches your problem for the owner evidence behind it.

3.5/5
Good
BedBoy Score
across 9 of 10 categories

Strongest on comfort and customer sentiment, weakest on durability.

  • Comfort 5.0/5 Show evidence for Comfort

    Comfort scored 5.0/5 from 253 owner reviews, each counted once: 51 lean positive and 14 lean negative (net signal +14.62%).

    • “Well-made mattress with external materials that have a premium look and feel. Perhaps less firm than might be expected for the 'extra firm' classification, but it seems to be just right for me - very comfortable and supportive (I'm 13.5 stone and 6ft tall).”
    • “Very firm mattress,just what I wanted,and so comfortable.”
    • “very comfortable took a few days to get used to it but love it now a lot lighter than my last mattress which was a orthopaedic”
  • Customer sentiment 4.5/5 Show evidence for Customer sentiment

    Customer sentiment scored 4.5/5 from an average star rating of 4.51 across 360 owner reviews.

  • Heat retention 4.0/5 Show evidence for Heat retention

    Heat retention scored 4.0/5 from traditional spring construction. Reviewer commentary specific to heat retention was limited (1 relevant mentions across 253 reviews) so the score relies on construction type.

  • Retailer guarantee 3.7/5 Show evidence for Retailer guarantee

    Retailer guarantee scored 3.7/5: 100-night comfort trial (one exchange after night 30, £49 fee), 5-year guarantee stated on the listing, and returns only if unopened, within 14 days and at your cost. Sub-scores: trial 5.0/5, warranty 4.0/5, returns 2.0/5.

  • Off-gassing and setup 3.5/5 Show evidence for Off-gassing and setup

    Off-gassing and setup scored 3.5/5 from compressed bed-in-box construction. Reviewer commentary specific to off-gassing and setup was limited (0 relevant mentions across 253 reviews) so the score relies on construction type.

  • Edge support 3.0/5 Show evidence for Edge support

    Edge support scored 3.0/5 from traditional spring construction. Reviewer commentary specific to edge support was limited (0 relevant mentions across 253 reviews) so the score relies on construction type.

  • Pressure relief 3.0/5 Show evidence for Pressure relief

    Pressure relief scored 3.0/5 from traditional spring construction. Reviewer commentary specific to pressure relief was limited (3 relevant mentions across 253 reviews) so the score relies on construction type.

    • “Good Points: Great support - no more aches and pains in the morning Improvement Points: No carry handles at the sides of the mattress”
    • “Good Points: Conducive with a good night's sleep with no aches and pains in the morning. Improvement Points: Dimple design”
  • Motion isolation 2.5/5 Show evidence for Motion isolation

    Motion isolation scored 2.5/5 from traditional spring construction. Reviewer commentary specific to motion isolation was limited (0 relevant mentions across 253 reviews) so the score relies on construction type.

    • “Improvement Points: I bought this mattress because the description said that everyone has their own comfort zone and I will not feel my partner turning, I am jumping up and down. I am very unsatisfied”
  • Durability 2.5/5 Show evidence for Durability

    Durability scored 2.5/5 from traditional spring construction. Reviewer commentary specific to durability was limited (2 relevant mentions across 253 reviews) so the score relies on construction type.

  • Value Too few mentions to score Value: Too few mentions to score. Not scored on this product.

Marked under v1.7, in force since . How the score is made.

Review

About the Silentnight Bonnell Mattress

This is about 19.5cm of mattress: one bonnell coil, two layers of polyester fibre and a knitted cover. I'd put it on a spare bed for a firm-sleeping adult who stays a few nights, and nowhere else. If you're buying your own nightly bed, a bed for two or a bed for a child, pay the extra for pocket springs.

An open coil, and why I rate it low

A bonnell unit is rows of steel springs wired to each other. Because they're joined, weight on one spring pulls its neighbours down, and the listing presents that as even support. My view is less kind. A joined-up coil wears unevenly, and the support goes soonest where you lie most. The worst mattress I've owned was an open coil, and that's where my low view starts.

Two layers sit between you and the wire: a packed layer of polyester fibre and a layer of soft white fibre. Two fibre layers make a short stack, and the wire is never far away. There's little in a build like this to keep heat in, so a cold sleeper will want a heavy duvet over a top this thin.

Firm, and who that suits

The only grade is Firm. Firm over a modest top is where I'd start a back or front sleeper near average weight. Lie on your back and the coil stops your hips dropping below your ribs. The fibre is too thin to fill in under your waist, so expect a flat, hard surface.

Side sleepers should skip it. Your shoulder and hip have to sink a little, and two fibre layers over a coil won't let them. On a lighter body it lies harder than the word Firm suggests. Heavier sleepers have a different problem: a joined-up coil gives way soonest where the most weight sits, so I'd spend more and buy pocket springs.

The reviews describe the bed it replaced

The reviews on this listing were written about the Silentnight Amsterdam Miracoil Ortho. That was an Extra Firm, 24cm mattress on a continuous coil, and the Bonnell took over its product code. So I read these reviews as a guide to what a firm coil feels like, not as a record of this bed.

Read as a guide, they're useful. Most owners liked the firm feel, and many say their backs felt better for it. The most common complaint runs the other way: too hard, with no give. After that come springs felt through the top, springs that creak and a bounce that crosses the bed when someone gets in. Each of those is what a firm coil under a thin top does, and the Bonnell is a shallower bed than the Amsterdam was.

Two sleepers, or a child

Two people is where a wired coil fails. When one of you turns, the wire carries it across to the other. Pocket springs are bagged one by one and don't pass movement on, so that's what a shared bed needs.

I wouldn't put a child on it every night either. A cheap open coil is where support goes first, and kids aren't where I'd save money.

Where a little more money goes

If the budget stretches, Silentnight's Miracoil beds at the same retailer use a continuous coil. That's a sounder build than open coil and honest value for one sleeper. The Air Plus 800 Mirapocket puts pocket springs under you inside a rod edge, and its grade is Medium to Firm. For a bed you'll use every night, that's the one I'd buy.

Pros and Cons

Pros

  • Graded Firm with only fibre on top, so an average-weight sleeper on their back or front lies flat.
  • Rolled and about 19.5cm deep: it goes up a narrow stair and takes a standard fitted sheet.
  • A five-year Silentnight guarantee on a cheap mattress.
  • Silentnight says it is made in the UK, with synthetic fibre fillings sold as hypoallergenic.

Cons

  • Open coil: the springs are laced into one lattice, so a partner's movement crosses the bed.
  • Thin fibre over wire, so side sleepers and anyone light will feel the coil.
  • Its owner reviews belong to the Amsterdam Miracoil it replaced.

Gary Ferguson Checked by Gary Ferguson, Research Writer

Checked on against the Mattress Online listing and the 253 of its 360 owner reviews with written comments.

Review analysis

What owners say about the Silentnight Bonnell Mattress

4.5/5

360 owner reviews

  • 360 from Mattress Online
  • 5 star 258 72%
  • 4 star 66 18%
  • 3 star 11 3%
  • 2 star 12 3%
  • 1 star 13 4%

BedBoy reads the owner reviews held for this listing and sums up what comes up most.

Most owners on this listing liked the firm feel, and many say it helped their backs, but those reviews were written about the Silentnight Amsterdam Miracoil Ortho that used this product code before. Too hard, with no give, is the complaint that leads. Next come springs felt through the top, creaking springs and a bounce that crosses the bed. Read them as what a firm coil does, not as a record of the Bonnell.

What owners bring up

How many of the 253 reviews with written comments (out of 360) come down one way or the other on each topic, each review counted once, and how many of those are praise.

Topics owners raise in 253 written reviews: how many reviews come down one way or the other on each, and the share of those reviews that are positive.
Topic Reviews Positive
Comfort 65 78%

Too few reviews on these yet to call: Edge support, motion isolation, heat retention, value, pressure relief, durability, off-gassing and setup.

Counted . How BedBoy counts review topics

Price history

Price Tracker

Prices recorded from 18 December 2023 to 21 November 2026.

Mattress Online £178 read 21 Nov 2026 Check price
Sizes

Sizes and prices

Price of the Silentnight Bonnell Mattress at Mattress Online by size
SizeDimensions (cm)Price
Single90 x 190£178
Small Double120 x 190£214
Double135 x 190£214
King150 x 200£244

Prices at Mattress Online on . Mattress Online showed crossed-out prices beside all 4 sizes, £195 beside the single.

Specification

Specification sheet

Guarantee
5 years
Depth
19.5 cm (listing also says 19 cm)
Spring type
Open coil, Rolled up, single-sided mattress, hypoallergenic
Comfort rating
Firm
Sleeping faces
Single-sided (one sleeping face)
Fillings
Polyester fibre
Cover
Knitted cover
Made in
UK
Fire resistance
Conforms to BS7177: 2008, for use at home
NBF approved
Yes
Rolled or boxed
Yes (rolled or boxed)
Trial
100 nights

What the spec implies

  • A 5-year guarantee ends well before the seven years a mattress is usually expected to last, so expect settlement exclusions.

  • Fire resistance means compliance with the Furniture and Furnishings (Fire) (Safety) Regulations 1988, mandatory across UK mattresses, not grounds to pay more.

  • NBF approval covers independent National Bed Federation checks on fire safety, clean fillings and honest labels, so judge comfort and lifespan from the build.

  • Body impressions are normal in a new mattress, so expect some dips without guarantee cover and check what depth qualifies.

Ownership

Care and guarantee

It is single-sided, so you never flip it: rotate it head to foot every week for the first three months, then once a month. It comes with a 5-year guarantee. Mattress Online’s 100-night comfort trial applies. After 30 nights you can swap a standalone mattress for another of the same size, once, for a £49 fee. It is an exchange, not a refund, and you must buy a protector from Mattress Online and use it from the first night.

Features

Key features

The retailer’s own feature list, with what each one means once the mattress is in your house.

Allergy care: Hypoallergenic

Hypoallergenic materials are chosen to provoke fewer allergic reactions, through anti-dust-mite treatments or fillings that do not shed fibres. It does not mean allergy-proof, so regular airing and a washable protector still matter.

Rolled-up

Rolled and vacuum-packed, the mattress travels in a compact box that is easy to carry upstairs and through tight doorways. Unwrap it on the bed frame and allow the recovery time its maker gives before judging depth and firmness.

Awards & accreditations: Handcrafted in the UK, Approved by the National Bed Federation

Two separate points: the maker says the mattress is built and hand finished in Britain, and the maker belongs to the National Bed Federation approval scheme, which audits fire safety compliance and honest product descriptions.

Fire resistance: Conforms to BS7177: 2008, for use at home

BS7177 is the British standard for the fire resistance of mattresses and bed bases; the home-use rating covers ignition from a smouldering cigarette and a lit match. Hotels and other contract settings need a higher rating.

Traditional open coil springs

Open coil means rows of springs joined into one wired unit, so the whole surface moves together and a partner's turns travel across the bed. It is a simple, firm, lower-cost build that suits guest beds and single sleepers.

National Bed Federation Approved Brand

The brand is a member of the National Bed Federation's Approved Bed Scheme, whose independent audits check members against the federation's code of practice. It covers how beds are made and labelled, not how they feel.

5 year guarantee

Fault cover puts manufacturing problems in writing, making a loose strut, failed fixing or collapsed padding less of a gamble after delivery. Accidental damage, fabric marks and poor fitting usually sit outside it.

Support system: Traditional Open Coil Springs

Open coil units join rows of springs with wire so they move together, giving a firm, even surface at a lower cost than pocket springs. Because the springs are linked, movement on one side carries across the bed.

Firm

Little sink: the surface holds your body near the top, keeping hips level with shoulders for back and front sleepers. Side sleepers want more give at the shoulder, so add a topper if you lie on your side.

Cover: Knitted cover

A knitted top stretches and moves with the layers under it, so the mattress contours to you without the fabric pulling tight. Loops in the knit catch on jewellery and claws, so keep a protector over it.

Knitted cover

Knitted fabric stretches with the comfort layers beneath it and lets air pass through its loops, so the surface feels soft and stays less stuffy than a tight woven cover. Use a protector to stop snags.

Firmness: Firm

Expect a short, shallow give at the top before the support stops you sinking any further. Back sleepers and heavier people get the most from it; side sleepers should check for a softer comfort layer.

Handcrafted in the UK

The maker says it is built and finished by hand at a British factory, with people stitching and fitting the layers. Hand assembly alone does not make a mattress more supportive or longer lasting.

Warranty: 5 Year Guarantee

For five years the maker repairs or replaces a mattress with a genuine fault in its springs, fillings or stitching. Ordinary wear, stains and natural settling are excluded from that cover.

Mattress type: Rolled Up, Single-Sided Mattress, Hypoallergenic

Boxed and rolled at the factory, it unrolls into a one-sided mattress. The maker lists it as hypoallergenic. Unwrap it promptly, since leaving it rolled for weeks slows full recovery.

Single-sided

Bed-making is simpler because the comfort layers stay on the top face, leaving the underside to stabilise the mattress while you lie on the cushioned surface. Don't flip it over.

Comfort fillings: Soft White Fibres

Soft white fibres are a polyester padding giving a light, cushioned top with no animal fibres in it. The padding flattens with use, so rotating the mattress keeps it even.

Soft White Fibres

Soft white fibres are a light filling that adds a soft, springy layer near the surface. Fibre fillings flatten with use, so rotate the mattress regularly.

Hypoallergenic

Hypoallergenic is the maker's word for fillings chosen to be low in common irritants. If dust mites bother you, wash the bedding on a hot wash every week.

Depth: 19cm

On a mattress, 19cm counts as a shallow build that takes a standard sheet easily and keeps the finished bed close to the floor.

Fire Resistant

The fillings and fabrics are made to resist catching light and to slow any flame.

19.5cm deep

Q&A

Questions about the Silentnight Bonnell Mattress

Answered by BedBoy from the product's specification and owner reviews.

Only rotating. There's a single sleeping side, which means the label stays face up and you spin it head to foot. Every few months is the listing's schedule. Silentnight's care booklet asks for a weekly rotation until the mattress is two or three months old, then a monthly one. Rotation is also a condition of the five-year guarantee, so I'd follow the booklet and write the dates down.

A flat, firm base or a frame with close slats. The booklet the listing links is a 2019 edition and allows gaps of up to 7.5cm. Silentnight's newer brochure sets 6cm. Keep your gaps to 6cm and both rules are met. Measure them with a tape before delivery.

Yes. It arrives vacuum packed and rolled, and the listing says that makes it easier to carry through tight stairwells and hallways. Cut it free on the frame itself, then give it 24 hours in a warm room to take its full shape before you sleep on it. Silentnight warns against bending it or rolling it back up yourself.

No. The listing gives 19 to 19.5cm, with a tolerance of 2cm either way. Standard fitted sheets are made for deeper mattresses than this one, so the sheets you own will cover it. A thin mattress does sit lower on the frame, so check the finished height if you find it hard to get up from a low bed.

You can exchange it, but you can't get your money back. The retailer's 100-night comfort trial asks for 30 nights on the mattress before a swap. It also only applies if you bought the retailer's own protector with it. Add the protector at checkout, keep it on from the first night, and claim the swap before night 100.

Faults in materials or workmanship, which Silentnight repairs or replaces at its choice. Its booklet treats some settling of the fillings as normal. It also refuses soiled mattresses and expects bed linen on the bed. Keep your proof of purchase, and fit a protector before the first night.

Verdict

BedBoy's verdict on the Silentnight Bonnell Mattress

A spare-room bed for one adult who likes it firm, and nothing more. For a nightly bed, a shared bed or a child's bed, buy pocket springs.

Gary Ferguson
Research Writer

If you share the bed every night, the Horizon Adventurer 1000 Pocket Memory Mattress at Mattress Online swaps the open coil for pocket springs, which move on their own so you feel less of a partner turning over, for £93 more in a double. It scores 4.0 against this one’s 3.5.

from £178 at Mattress Online, read 21 Nov 2026
Check price at Mattress Online

BedBoy earns a commission when you buy through a retailer link. The commission never changes a score. How this works

Compare

Alternatives to compare

The three nearest Mattress Online listings. Depth is where they differ most from the Silentnight Bonnell Mattress: 26 cm and 25 cm against its 19.5 cm.

Silentnight Bonnell Mattress against 3 alternatives
Listing BedBoy Score From FirmnessDepthTrial Compare
This mattressSilentnight Bonnell Mattress 3.5/5 Good £178 Firm19.5 cm100 nights
Classic Gold Ortho Mattress 3.7/5 Good £178 Medium Firm (differs from this page) 26 cm (differs from this page) 100 nights Compare side by side
Romantica Adagio Extra Firm Mattress 3.8/5 Good £184 Firm 25 cm (differs from this page) 100 nights Compare side by side
Romantica Serenade Ortho Mattress 3.8/5 Good £169 Firm 25 cm (differs from this page) 100 nights Compare side by side

differs from this mattress

Compare all three →

Same retailer

More mattresses from Mattress Online

Other Mattress Online listings BedBoy scores.

Retailer service

What Trustpilot says about Mattress Online

Trustpilot rates Mattress Online as a shop: delivery, returns and service. This product's own reviews are above.

Choosing a mattress? Three questions on how you sleep, your build and any back or neck pain give you a firmness band to start from. Take the mattress quiz

If you spot a wrong price, a specification that doesn't match the retailer's listing or a score that looks off, report it through the corrections page, where BedBoy logs every fix with its date.