BedBoy earns a commission when you buy through a retailer link. The commission never changes a score. How this works
Compare

Romantica Adagio Extra Firm vs Silentnight Bonnell Mattress

Two mattresses, both sold by Mattress Online

The short answer

The Romantica Adagio Extra Firm scores higher, 3.8 against 3.5, with its widest lead on off-gassing and setup (5.0 against 3.5). The Silentnight Bonnell costs £10 less in a double (£214 against £224). The Silentnight Bonnell has too few reviews yet to mark value, so its score rests on fewer categories.

  1. Romantica Adagio Extra Firm

    at Mattress Online

    3.8/5 Good

    £224 Double

    Check price

    Why pick it

    • Scores higher on off-gassing and setup: 5.0 against 3.5
    • Double-sided: flip and rotate
  2. Silentnight Bonnell

    at Mattress Online

    3.5/5 Good

    £214 Double

    Check price

    Why pick it

    • Longer guarantee: 5 years, against 1 year
    • Never needs flipping: rotate it only
Price

Price and sizes

Price and sizes for Romantica Adagio Extra Firm, Silentnight Bonnell
DetailRomantica Adagio Extra FirmSilentnight Bonnell
Price in a double
£224 £255
£214 £239Lowest
Single 90 x 190 cm
£184 £195
£178 £195Lowest
King 150 x 200 cm
£274 £295
£244 £269Lowest
Small Double 120 x 190 cm
£224 £255
£214 £239Lowest

Prices read from each retailer on 22 November 2026. The retailer’s checkout has the final price.

Rating

BedBoy Score

BedBoy Score for Romantica Adagio Extra Firm, Silentnight Bonnell
DetailRomantica Adagio Extra FirmSilentnight Bonnell
BedBoy Score
3.8/5 GoodBest
3.5/5 Good
Comfort
5.0/5
5.0/5
Pressure relief
3.0/5
3.0/5
Edge support
3.0/5
3.0/5
Motion isolation
2.5/5
2.5/5
Heat retention
4.0/5
4.0/5
Durability
2.5/5
2.5/5
Value
5.0/5
Too few reviews
Off-gassing and setup
5.0/5Best
3.5/5
Customer sentiment
4.6/5
4.5/5
Retailer guarantee
3.0/5
3.7/5Best
Same on both: Comfort 5.0 · Pressure relief 3.0 · Edge support 3.0 · Motion isolation 2.5 · Heat retention 4.0 · Durability 2.5

Each mark is out of 5, from owner reviews and the specification. How the score is made.

Owner reviews

What owners say

What owners say for Romantica Adagio Extra Firm, Silentnight Bonnell
DetailRomantica Adagio Extra FirmSilentnight Bonnell
Owners rate it
4.6/5 664 reviews
4.5/5 360 reviews
Comfort
75% positive 60 mentions
78% positive 65 mentions
Value
95% positive 55 mentions
Too few mentions

Share of the reviews that mention each topic which are positive about it, out of the reviews with written comments. How the counts work.

Feel

Firmness and feel

Firmness and feel for Romantica Adagio Extra Firm, Silentnight Bonnell
DetailRomantica Adagio Extra FirmSilentnight Bonnell
Firmness
Firm
Firm
Edge support
Reinforced edge
Not stated
Same on both: Firmness Firm
Construction

What it is made of

What it is made of for Romantica Adagio Extra Firm, Silentnight Bonnell
DetailRomantica Adagio Extra FirmSilentnight Bonnell
Build
Open coil
Open coil
Depth
25 cm
19.5 cm (listing also says 19 cm)
Spring type
Open coil, Double-sided mattress, orthopaedic
Open coil, Rolled up, single-sided mattress, hypoallergenic
Tufting
Hand-tufted
Not stated
Fillings
Polyester fibre
Polyester fibre
Cover
Damask cover
Knitted cover
Made in
UK
UK
Fire resistance
Conforms to BS7177: 2008, for use at home
Conforms to BS7177: 2008, for use at home
NBF approved
Not stated
Yes
Rolled or boxed
Not stated
Yes (rolled or boxed)
Same on both: Build Open coil · Fillings Polyester fibre · Made in UK · Fire resistance Conforms to BS7177: 2008, for use at home
Buying terms

Trial, guarantee and care

Trial, guarantee and care for Romantica Adagio Extra Firm, Silentnight Bonnell
DetailRomantica Adagio Extra FirmSilentnight Bonnell
Trial
100 nightsComfort trial (one exchange after night 30, £49 fee)
100 nightsComfort trial (one exchange after night 30, £49 fee)
Guarantee
1 year
5 yearsBest
Returns
Returns only if unopened, within 14 days and at your cost
Returns only if unopened, within 14 days and at your cost
Turning
Flip and rotate
Rotate only, no flipping
Sleeping faces
Double-sided (two sleeping faces)
Single-sided (one sleeping face)
Same on both: Trial 100 nights · Returns only if unopened, within 14 days and at your cost
Where to buy

Romantica Adagio Extra Firm

£224 at Mattress Online

Check price

Silentnight Bonnell

£214 at Mattress Online

Check price

Questions about this comparison

How is the BedBoy Score worked out?

The score is the plain average of the category marks for that product type. BedBoy marks each listing using the customer reviews held against it and the seller's published specification, with a mark from how the product is built where reviewers say little about a category. The categories depend on the product type. Read how the score is made for the detail behind those marks.

Are the prices on this page live?

No. Each price is the figure BedBoy last read from the retailer, and the date under the price table tells you when that was. A sale price can come and go between reads, so check the retailer's checkout before you pay.

Why is the same product listed once per retailer?

Trial length, warranty and returns differ by shop. Each listing is tied to a retailer because the same mattress can leave you with different rights if it turns out wrong, depending on where you bought it. Compare the terms as well as what you'll pay. The retailer guarantee row is marked on that shop's trial, warranty and returns terms.